The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed the Jalandhar Improvement Trust (JIT) to pay Rs 32 lakh, including a refund of Rs 7.66 lakh, to two allottees of its Indrapuram (Master Gurbanta Singh Enclave) housing scheme together with 9 per cent interest, for failing to deliver flats with pledged basic amenities even after receiving the payments.

The commission also directed the trust to pay Rs 30,000 each as compensation for mental harassment and Rs 10,000 each towards litigation expenses in two separate orders. It has given the JIT 45 days from the receipt of the orders to comply with, failing which a further 3 per cent annual interest will be payable on the deposited amounts.

In the first case, the commission directed the refund of Rs 4.03 lakh to Sandeep Kumar, a Jalandhar resident who was allotted an LIG flat on the ground floor of Block A through a lucky draw on June 13, 2006.

विज्ञापनIn-Article Banner

The allotment letter was issued on September 4, 2006. In spite of paying the whole amount in installments, he was not given physical possession of the flat with all vowed facilities. After calculating the interest on his payment, Kumar is liable to receive a payout of close to Rs 16 lakh.

As per the allotment conditions, the JIT was needed to hand over the possession within two-and-a-half years by March 2009. However, Kumar alleged that basic amenities, including electricity and a 45-foot wide approach road, were unavailable even after years of waiting.

The trust maintained that the construction had been wrapped up and possession offered while also challenging the complaint on grounds of limitation and maintainability under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act.

The commission ordered a refund of Rs 3.63 lakh to Ravi Bhushan Mahindru, a 59-year-old resident of Ahiyapur village in Tanda, Hoshiarpur in the second case. He was allotted an LIG flat on the first floor of Block A under the same scheme in 2006.

Mahindru alleged that JIT officials obtained his signature on a possession memo at their office on October 14, 2009, without handing over actual physical possession. He found the flat and surrounding infrastructure incomplete on visiting the site. He also alleged that substandard construction material had been used and the vowed piped LPG facility and community hall had not been provided. Mahindru is also liable to obtain the payment of Rs 16 lakh from the trust, including interest and refund.

The commission observed that JIT had did not manage to produce convincing evidence to establish that the flats and the surrounding infrastructure had been completed in all respects in both cases. It also noted the absence of completion and occupancy certificates.

Rejecting the trust's objections, the commission held that an offer or paper handover of possession without essential facilities and statutory clearances can not be treated as valid delivery. It observed that home buyers could not be made to wait indefinitely for possession and held the JIT deficient in service and negligent in fulfilling its obligations.