The Punjab and Haryana High Court has set aside the cancellation of the registration of Gurdwara Shaheed Ganj Sahib Parbhandhak Committee, imposing Rs 50,000 costs on the state and another respondent for “recalcitrant attitude”. The sum was directed to be deposited in the Poor Patients Welfare Fund, PGIMER, Chandigarh, within four weeks.

Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya held that the impugned communication was an illegal and non-speaking order. The court restored the committee's registration under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, while leaving the officials free to take appropriate action in accordance with law after following due process.

The court observed: "It is apparent on record that the impugned memo cancelling the committee’s registration is a cryptic non-speaking order that has been passed without even issuing a show-cause notice to it. This makes the order illegal." The petitioner panel was represented by advocates Harsh Chopra and Gurjeet Singh.

विज्ञापनIn-Article Banner

Justice Dahiya’s Bench was told that the Additional Registrar of Societies, Jalandhar, issued a registration certificate to the committee on April 3, 2023. However, within two days, the registration was scrapped through a memo dated April 6, 2023.

The petitioner challenged the cancellation as being "in violation of the settled principles of law". The petitioner's counsel argued that the registration had been cancelled "without assigning any reason", rendering the action unsustainable on account of violation of natural justice.

The cancellation memo merely stated that an objection had been received against the registration and, therefore, "after registration, the registered committee is hereby cancelled".

Justice Dahiya also took note of the respondents' failure to comply with repeated opportunities to file their written statement. “Despite availing several opportunities, the respondents have not filed their written statement. On July 20, they were granted a last opportunity to file the same by September 2, failing which it was to be accepted on payment of Rs 25,000 as costs to be deposited with the Poor Patients Welfare Fund, PGIMER, Chandigarh”.

The Bench added the written statement was still not lodged. “On September 2, a statement was made on their behalf that the written statement would be placed on record before the next date of hearing after payment of costs imposed vide the last order. Even today, the position remains unchanged, as the written statement has not been filed, nor have the costs been deposited,” Justice Dahiya noted.

The Bench added: “The memo dated April 6, 2023, is set aside, and as a consequence the registration of the committee granted vide certificate dated April 3, 2023, stands restored. The respondents will be at liberty to take appropriate action against the petitioner, as may be required, in accordance with law after complying with the principles of natural justice. Also, for recalcitrant attitude the respondents are burdened with costs of Rs 50,000…,” Justice Dahiya wrapped up.