District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed the Jalandhar Improvement Trust (JIT) to pay approximately Rs 61 lakh to four allottees of its Indrapuram (Master Gurbanta Singh Enclave) housing initiative after finding that the trust had did not manage to provide liveable flats and promised basic amenities despite collecting payments years ago.

In four separate orders, the commission directed JIT to refund a total of Rs 16.20 lakh deposited by the allottees together with 9 per cent annual interest from the respective dates of payment. The total pay-out including accumulated interest, is estimated at about Rs 61 lakh. The trust has also been directed to pay each complainant Rs 30,000 as compensation for mental agony and harassment and Rs 10,000 towards litigation expenses.

Reportedly, the four allottees had been granted low income group (LIG) flats in Block A of the initiative, for which they had paid between Rs 3.90 lakh and Rs 4.30 lakh each. Yet, they alleged that the possession handed over by JIT was only on paper as the flats lacked basic amenities and were not fit for occupation.

विज्ञापनIn-Article Banner

The complainants Ajit Kumar Sharma of Tanda and Hemant Kumar, Vishal Ahuja and Rajni Badyal of Jalandhar stated that although they had inked possession documents between 2009 and 2010, they could not occupy the flats as various vital works at the site remained incomplete.

Their grievances highlighted the lack of proper electricity and water supply, unconnected sewerage lines and inadequate approach roads. They also expressed concern over poor construction quality and the use of substandard material to build their flats.

To support their claims, the allottees submitted photographs, technical reports, newspaper reports and correspondence between JIT and the residents' welfare society.

JIT contested the grievances, arguing that the allottees had accepted possession several years ago and had raised no objections at the time. It maintained that the flats had been wrapped up as per the allotment conditions and relied on possession slips signed by the complainants, which recorded that the construction, water supply, sewerage and electrification work was satisfactory. The trust also argued that the flats had been handed over in a semi-finished condition and that their maintenance was the responsibility of the allottees.

Rejecting the trust's arguments, the commission observed that JIT had could not establish that the flats and promised facilities had been wrapped up. It also noted that the trust had not produced the completion certificate needed under the Punjab Apartment and Property Regulation Act, 1995.

The commission held that signing a possession document did not sum to handing over complete possession when basic facilities and needed approvals were missing. It also dismissed JIT's argument that the complaints were time barred, observing that the allottees continued to have grounds for complaint until the promised facilities and valid possession are provided.

The commission directed JIT to refund the deposited amounts with 9 per cent annual interest, besides paying compensation and litigation expenses. The trust has been given 45 days from receiving the orders to comply, failing which an extra 3 percent annual interest will be payable on the deposited amounts.